Writing Without a Scorecard

Published by

on

mind map to get ideas out

Somewhere along the way, writing picked up a scorecard. Word counts became flexes. Posting schedules sprints. Engagement metrics act like referees… you keep up or fall behind. Writing starts to feel less like thinking out loud and more like a competition.

This week’s readings circle the same idea from different perspectives. Content matters, context matters more and length only matters when it serves a purpose. What none of them argue for is writing as a contest. Yet that is how many of us approach it.

Writing is Not a Contest, Literally

William Zinsser makes this point in On Writing Well. He argues, writing is not a contest. There are no winners, rankings or finish lines. Comparing your work to someone else’s only pulls attention away from the thing that matters. Saying what you want to say.

When writing becomes about outperforming others, clarity suffers. Voice flattens. The work starts chasing approval instead of meaning. Go at your “own pace” because the “only competition is with yourself.”

Content is King, Not Content as a Competition

Bill Gates’ “Content is King” essay is quoted constantly to produce faster and louder content. Too often, content is rushed to fill space. But Gates was not arguing for volume. He was arguing for substance.

Content only wins when it delivers real value. There is no prize for showing up first. Your content should say something, otherwise it will strike out.

Context Changes the Rules of Writing

Gary Vaynerchuk’s reminder that “context is god” pushes this further. If you have ever shared something you believed in and watched it fall flat, you understand why.

The same idea can succeed or fail depending on timing, platform, audience and intent. That alone breaks the idea of writing as a contest. Your work is not racing anyone else’s. It is meeting someone at a specific moment.

Length is a Tool, Not a Ranking System

The long-form debate tends to treat length like proof of effort. HubSpot makes the case that length is a strategy.

In practice, that usually means one of two things:

  • Sometimes a topic needs room to breathe and earn trust.
  • Other times, the strongest move is getting in, making the point and getting out.

Writing more than necessary is not ambition. It is noise.

There is No Finish Line

Good writing is not about beating someone to the punch. It is about saying something clear, useful or honest in a way that fits the moment.

No medals. No podium. In fact there never was a scorecard. Your content will always win when you write with context and intent.

This post is written by a human, and made as a comparison to an AI generated blog post. The AI generated one is titled “Stop Trying to “Win” Your Writing: Why Content Isn’t a Contest”.


References:

Carmicheal, K. (2020, June 9). The Ins and Outs of Writing Long-Form Content. Blog.hubspot.com. 

Evans, H. (2017, October 28). “Content is King” — Essay by Bill Gates 1996. Medium. 

Vaynerchuk, G. (2016, March 1). Content is King, But Context is God. Gary Vaynerchuk.

Zinsser, W. (2016). On Writing Well: The Classic Guide to Writing Nonfiction. Harperperennial.

Leave a comment

No comments to show.